California AB 489: Who Is Giving This Advice?
Outline
A fictional practice is testing a between-session feature. The onboarding screen says the replies are generated by software. A client then receives a bubble headed “Dr. Lin, your psychologist” followed by individualized health advice. The push preview repeats the same title.
The response bubble is the precise misleading surface: its title presents the software’s advice as the work of a licensed person. The onboarding disclosure does not erase what the client sees in the reply, and the push preview repeats the problem. Hold the release. Do not try to cure it with a footer or a license number.
Ask the supplier to identify who authored each item and demonstrate the corrected experience across the onboarding screen, reply, and push preview. If wording remains uncertain, take the exact surfaces to practice counsel before release. In the meantime, offer a clinician-authored question such as, “What would you like me to know before our next session?”
Keep the three-surface decision record
Use the Who Appears to Be Speaking? decision record to capture the exact phrase, its actual source, the client’s likely inference, and who owns the hold and retest.
Review AI Advice Attribution
Use this sheet this week to compare the client-facing wording with its actual human or software source.
- Illinois Session Transcription Decision and Consent Record
- Nevada Post-Session Notes and Billing Review Sheet
- Utah Chatbot and Clinician Disclosure Timing Card
- Psychiatry Portal Message Release Card, Who Appears to Be Speaking?, and State-by-Feature Release Sheet
Free. We'll email the PDF link right away and add you to the therapist toolkit, sent every two weeks. Unsubscribe any time.
Where should we send the link?
We'll email the PDF link right away. You'll also get the therapist toolkit every two weeks. Unsubscribe any time.
✓ Check your inbox
We've sent you the PDF
The download link is on its way to your inbox, usually within a minute or two. The email will come from Emosapien (hello@team.emosapien.com); check your spam folder if you don't see it.
You're also on the therapist toolkit list, sent every two weeks. Unsubscribe any time from the email footer.
Start with the real client journey rather than a supplier’s summary. Capture what a person sees before sign-in, in the response itself, and in a notification preview. Save the exact words and surrounding context. Use an invented case only; do not include client information in a test record.
California AB 489 was signed October 11, 2025, and became operative January 1, 2026. Business and Professions Code sections 4999.8 and 4999.9 address AI and generative AI system advertising or functionality using terms, letters, or phrases that indicate or imply that health care advice, care, reports, or assessments are provided by a natural person with the appropriate license or certificate. Each prohibited use is a separate violation. The statute applies across professions licensed or regulated under the relevant division and initiative acts; do not extend this California rule to another state.
The Board advisory discusses AI use by licensees and registrants. It is guidance, not a determination about a particular product or label. Read the statutory text and current Board material, then bring unresolved application questions to practice counsel.
For related ethics guidance, see ethical documentation practices for AI therapy.
Inspect function before title
For California AB 489, record the exact wording, including punctuation, placement, and screen. Assess the implication created by the full interaction, not only whether a disclaimer appears.
A software label on one screen does not resolve a conflicting title on another. Review the welcome page, each generated response, and push previews as separate client-facing surfaces. Test the ordinary path and likely return visits, including a notification that may be read without opening the app. If a phrase makes the automated source sound like the client’s licensed psychologist, pause the release and request a corrected experience across all affected surfaces.
Ask the supplier for an item-level account of authorship: which text is generated, which text is supplied by a clinician, and which names or titles appear in each location. Request a demonstration of the revised path, not a promise to change a general policy. If the supplier cannot identify the source of each item, record that gap and keep the feature on hold. A license number or generic disclaimer does not answer who produced the advice or what a client could reasonably infer.
California law applies to the wording and functionality described in AB 489. Assess professional duties, practice policies, privacy obligations, supervision arrangements, and contracts separately. Do not assume that a client consent form makes a prohibited use permissible. Ask counsel to assess unresolved wording or application questions.
Decide whether to pause, revise, or proceed under California AB 489
Use a consistent review sequence for each surface:
- Capture the client view. Save a screenshot or exact text of the onboarding statement, response, and notification preview. Use a fictional test profile and invented details, never a de-identified real note.
- Identify the actual source. Ask whether the item is generated by software, authored by a clinician, or edited and approved by a clinician. Avoid treating a person’s name in the interface as proof of authorship.
- Compare title and function. Check whether a title, first-person voice, or phrase could imply that a natural person holding the appropriate license provided the advice. Record the exact wording and its placement.
- Hold unclear cases. If the experience conflicts across screens or leaves authorship uncertain, stop release and request a corrected demonstration across all three surfaces.
- Escalate unresolved wording. Send counsel the statutory text, Board advisory, screenshots, and supplier’s written account. Ask counsel to assess how the law applies to the specific product and workflow.
The statute was signed on October 11, 2025, and became operative on January 1, 2026. Statutory text checked November 2026.
Keep evidence of the review
Keep the dated screenshots or exact text for the welcome screen, response bubble, and push preview; the supplier’s explanation of authorship; the requested and demonstrated revisions; the reviewer and decision owner; and any counsel follow-up. Note which version was tested and what remains unresolved. Restrict access and retention according to your practice policy. Record the date, device, account type, and route used for each test so another reviewer can reproduce the same client view.
Do not use real client notes merely after removing a name. HIPAA Safe Harbor requires removal of 18 categories of identifiers, including identifiers of relatives, employers, and household members, and no actual knowledge that the remaining information could identify the person. Expert Determination is a separate method. For a broader review of how vendors handle protected health information, see the HIPAA privacy scan for vendors. Consult the HHS guidance on de-identification before making claims about de-identification. A signed business associate agreement, where required, does not by itself satisfy HIPAA, professional duties, or state law.
Emosapien’s Engagement Agent supports guided check-ins, journaling, and homework between sessions. Scores trend against treatment-plan objectives. Client engagement is available on Professional and Enterprise, not Free or Starter.
Record the client’s choice where you document care
Record the client’s choice and the actual workflow in the appropriate practice record, following your policies. Keep the product-attribution review separate from a consent form: explain the feature and how the client can contact the practice. If the client declines, follow the practice’s established alternative. Revisit the review when the supplier changes wording or functionality, and consult counsel when the application of AB 489 remains uncertain.
Guided support between sessions
Explore guided check-ins, journaling, and homework on Professional and Enterprise.
Get Started- Free plan
- No credit card
Written by clinician
What would you like me to know before our next session?
Software-generated
Consider one thing you would like to discuss.
References
- California Assembly Bill 489, Business and Professions Code sections 4999.8 and 4999.9, signed October 11, 2025; operative January 1, 2026; checked November 2026.
- California Board of Psychology, “AB 489 (Bonta) Chapter 615, Statutes of 2025 - Health care professions: deceptive terms or letters: artificial intelligence”, checked November 2026.
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, “Guidance Regarding Methods for De-identification of Protected Health Information”, checked November 2026.
Related reading
ACA AI Recommendations: Test a Tool Before Client Use
Apply ACA AI recommendations to a fictional three-case acceptance test of a check-in prompt writer before considering client use.
Read article →AI for School Counselors: Check a Caregiver Invitation
Check an AI-drafted caregiver invitation for unapproved disclosures, verify the recipient and channel, and document your decision.
Read article →Free PDF: State AI Therapy Law Decision Records
Six state-specific decision sheets for documenting how a planned AI workflow is reviewed, held, disclosed, or released.
- Illinois Session Transcription Decision and Consent Record
- Nevada Post-Session Notes and Billing Review Sheet
- Utah Chatbot and Clinician Disclosure Timing Card
- Psychiatry Portal Message Release Card, Who Appears to Be Speaking?, and State-by-Feature Release Sheet
Free. We'll email the PDF link right away and add you to the therapist toolkit, sent every two weeks. Unsubscribe any time.
Where should we send the link?
We'll email the PDF link right away. You'll also get the therapist toolkit every two weeks. Unsubscribe any time.
✓ Check your inbox
We've sent you the PDF
The download link is on its way to your inbox, usually within a minute or two. The email will come from Emosapien (hello@team.emosapien.com); check your spam folder if you don't see it.
You're also on the therapist toolkit list, sent every two weeks. Unsubscribe any time from the email footer.