Closed case folder and brass compass within a sage boundary circle on a lamp-lit desk
ethicscounselingdocumentationcomplianceboundaries

Ethical Problems in Counseling: Six Worked Cases

Photo of Andrew Evans
Andrew Evans Clinical Operations Writer 8 min read
ProblemCode standardFirst stepWhat to document
ConfidentialityACA 2014 B.1.c, B.1.dDo not confirm; restate limitsRequest, refusal, limits restated
Dual relationshipACA 2014 A.6.b, A.6.cDecline if you can still walk awayInvitation, decline, rationale
CompetenceACA 2014 C.2.a, C.2.bName the limit; refer or get supervisionPresenting need, training edge, next step
Informed consentACA 2014 A.2.a, A.2.b, B.6.dPause the change; get permissionWhat changed, what you explained
DocumentationACA 2014 A.1.bKeep the clinically necessary lineRequest to omit, what you recorded
TerminationACA 2014 A.11.c, A.12Give notice; arrange transferNotice date, referrals, remaining plan

Educational cases for US counselors working under the 2014 ACA Code of Ethics. Not legal advice, not a board ruling, and not a substitute for the code PDF, supervision, or counsel.

The 4:12 p.m. voicemail is from a spouse. They already know the Thursday time. They only want you to say Renee still comes. That is one of the ethical problems in counseling you can settle in the hour, if you open the standard instead of improvising a courtesy yes.

Six ethical problems in counseling

Each row is a worked case. Open the 2014 ACA Code of Ethics to the section number, take the first step, and write the chart line. If the standard you actually read is specific and clear, follow it and stop. If it is not, fill the ACA ethical decision making model before you act.

Confidentiality

Problem: A spouse leaves a voicemail asking you to confirm that an adult client still attends on Thursdays. There is no valid authorization for that person.

Code standard: ACA 2014 B.1.c (respect for confidentiality) and B.1.d (explanation of limitations). B.1.c says you protect confidential information of prospective and current clients and disclose only with appropriate consent or with sound legal or ethical justification. B.2.a is the harm-and-law exception; a scheduling curiosity is not that exception.

First step: Do not confirm attendance, even with a “yes, they are still coming.” Call the client, not the spouse. Restate the limits you already gave at intake. If the client wants the spouse informed, get appropriate consent before you disclose. B.1.c requires that consent; it does not list the form fields. Use the written authorization your practice already uses under applicable privacy law.

What to document: Who asked, that you did not disclose, the limits you restated, whether you offered an authorization, and the client’s instruction. No extra family narrative.

You already explained confidentiality at intake. B.1.d says you keep explaining the limits as the work continues. A voicemail is one of those hours. If the call is actually a safety concern, stop using this row and read B.2.a on the facts in front of you.

Dual relationship

Problem: A current adult client invites you to their weekend hiking group. Another group exists in town. The invite is social, not a treatment task.

Code standard: ACA 2014 A.6.b (extending counseling boundaries) and A.6.c (documenting boundary extensions). A.6.b tells you to consider risks and benefits before you extend the relationship beyond conventional parameters, and to use consent, consultation, supervision, and documentation so judgment is not impaired and no harm occurs. A hiking group is a second social role you can still decline.

First step: Decline. Do not “try one hike and see.” If you feel pulled, consult before you answer, not after you have already gone. A date with a current client is a different problem; that one is prohibited under A.5.a and has no managed version.

What to document: The invitation, your decline, the rationale, and any consultation. Write it before the weekend when feasible, which is what A.6.c asks for on an extension you might actually make.

If you still have to sort prohibited, avoidable, or managed, use the dual relationships in therapy card. Do not paste a graduation example onto a hiking invite.

Competence

Problem: A current client asks you to add EMDR for trauma nightmares. You completed a weekend introduction. You have no supervised EMDR caseload and no consultant.

Code standard: ACA 2014 C.2.a (boundaries of competence) and C.2.b (new specialty areas of practice). C.2.a limits practice to education, training, supervised experience, credentials, and appropriate professional experience. C.2.b says you enter a new specialty only after appropriate education, training, and supervised experience, and you protect others from possible harm while you develop the skill.

First step: Name the limit in the room. Do not sell the weekend course as protocol competence. Offer a referral to a qualified EMDR clinician, or pause the new method until you have supervision that actually covers this client. You can keep the existing anxiety work if that work is inside your training.

What to document: The request, your training edge in one sentence, what you offered (referral, consultation, or both), and the client’s choice. Do not write “EMDR initiated” after a slide deck.

A new method you saw on a slide is still a new specialty. C.2.b is the stop, not a suggestion to read one more manual overnight.

Problem: You want a practicum student to sit in next week. The current consent form never mentioned observation, recording, or a third person in the room.

Code standard: ACA 2014 A.2.a (informed consent), A.2.b (types of information needed), and B.6.d (permission to observe). A.2.a requires an ongoing informed-consent process, in writing and verbally, so the client can choose whether to enter or remain. A.2.b requires you to explain techniques, procedures, limitations, the role of technology, and other pertinent information. B.6.d is the permission standard: you obtain permission from the client before anyone observes a session, reviews a transcript, or views a recording with supervisors, faculty, peers, or others in a training setting.

First step: Do not add the student next week on a hallway yes. Pause the change. Walk the update out loud, put observation on the form, and wait for permission. A declined observer is a declined observer.

What to document: What would change, what you explained, the client’s decision, and the date. If they decline, the student does not sit in “just this once.”

The blank the client signs is the informed consent form for counseling. Fill that form for the change. Do not bury a new person in the room inside an intake checkbox from six months ago.

Documentation

Problem: A client in a custody dispute asks you to leave last week’s suicidal-ideation screen out of the note because a parent may see the portal.

Code standard: ACA 2014 A.1.b (records and documentation). A.1.b says counselors create, safeguard, and maintain documentation necessary for rendering professional services. Do not delete or rewrite a clinically necessary line at a client’s request; follow your agency’s policy for any requested amendment and preserve the original record. A.1.b says that if amendments are made, you properly note them according to agency or institutional policies.

First step: Keep the clinically necessary line. Explain what the record is for, what the portal may show, and what you can do about access (a more limited note, a delay your policy actually allows, a safety plan the client can hold). Do not promise a blank.

What to document: The request to omit, the screen result in the client’s words as needed for care, the safety steps, and what you explained about records. No extra custody narrative.

A portal-visibility problem is an access problem. It is not permission to erase a risk assessment. If you are a social worker on a records-and-risk hour, switch to the social work ethical dilemmas examples and the NASW Code. Do not drag ACA A.1.b into that code.

If software drafted the note, also check whether it pulled a finding from a different date. You can practice spotting a wrong-visit detail in a Claude draft with invented records.

Termination

Problem: You are closing the practice in six weeks. A high-risk client has no receiving clinician yet.

Code standard: ACA 2014 A.11.c (appropriate termination) and A.12 (abandonment and client neglect). A.11.c requires pretermination counseling and recommended other service providers when necessary. A.12 says you do not abandon or neglect clients, and you assist with continuation of treatment when necessary, including after termination.

First step: Give dated notice now, not in week five. Offer pretermination sessions. Recommend other service providers you can actually name. A.11.c requires that recommendation when necessary; it does not set a count or a wait-time check. Keep crisis instructions in writing. A.11.d adds that a transfer needs the clinical and administrative steps completed, not a name scribbled on a sticky note.

What to document: Notice date, what you said, referrals offered (names and how to reach them), the client’s response, remaining session dates, and the crisis path until the last hour.

Closing a practice is a termination plan. It is not a disappearing act. If the client refuses every referral, you still document the offers and the remaining access you can actually provide through the end date.

Worked example

Ethics log template

Keep the six ethical problems in counseling in the chart, not in a side notebook you will lose. If the next hour is a true dilemma, fill the decision-making sheet.

Keep the chart clear

Review a session-note draft before signing, so the clinical record keeps the decision and next step.

Review a draft
  • No credit card
Documentation review
Fictional · Confidentiality call

Micah documented

No information was disclosed without authorization.

Clinician review

Micah confirms the note after checking the standard.

Review the progress-note draft →

References

Get the therapist toolkit

Practical, plainspoken notes on AI for therapy practices. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

By subscribing you agree to get the Emosapien therapist toolkit by email every two weeks. We never share your email. Unsubscribe any time.

Ready to transform your practice?

Join 10,000+ therapists using Emosapien.