A blank card between a tabbed binder and desk calendar, circled in marigold
borderline personality disordersuicide riskclinical documentationrisk assessmentbpd

Borderline Personality Disorder and Suicide Rates

Photo of Dr. James Whitfield
Dr. James Whitfield UK & EU Practice Editor 8 min read
Outline
FigureValueSource and populationWhat it changes in the note
Lifetime completed suicideUp to 10%Paris 2019 review of clinical BPD samplesDo not treat chronic SI as low intent
24-year completed suicide5.9% vs 1.4% comparisonTemes 2019, 290 McLean inpatientsName the cohort; not a universal rate
Lifetime attempt historyAt least 75%Black 2004 clinical reviewAttempt history is expected, not rare
Attempts at index (inpatient)79% any; 60% multipleZanarini 2008, McLean inpatientsRecord count and method, not “SI+“
Mean lifetime attemptsAbout 3, mostly overdoseParis 2019 clinical reviewWrite method and count, not a label
Attempts in years 9 to 1012.8% in that intervalZanarini 2008, same McLean cohortReassess; a falling rate is not zero risk
Completed suicides in pooled cohorts94 of 1,179 (about 8%)Pompili 2005, eight follow-up studiesRisk is higher early in follow-up
Prior hospitalizationsHazard ratio 1.62Temes 2019 McLean inpatientsPut admission count in the formulation
Recovery before suicide death87.5% not recoveredTemes 2019 McLean inpatientsTrack function, not diagnosis alone

Educational reference for licensed mental health clinicians. It is not crisis advice or a substitute for your clinical judgment, supervisor, or local emergency protocol. If a client is in immediate danger, follow your local emergency pathway. In the US, SAMHSA states that you can call or text 988 (988 FAQs).

A client with three overdoses sits in front of you. Someone on the team quotes the 10 percent completed-suicide figure as if it settles today’s risk. It does not. Borderline personality disorder and suicide rates tell you the base rate in a studied group. They do not tell you whether this person leaves the room alive.

Use the table as a citation map. Pick the row that matches the population you are actually talking about, then write this client’s factors, your judgment, and the action that followed.

Using borderline personality disorder and suicide rates in the note

A rate is a property of a sample. Paris’s 2019 review of clinical literature puts lifetime completed suicide as high as 10 percent, with a mean of about three lifetime attempts, mostly by overdose. That is a treated-sample figure, not a community census.

Temes and colleagues followed 290 adults who met both DIB-R and DSM-III-R criteria for BPD after a McLean Hospital inpatient stay between 1992 and 1995. Over 24 years, 5.9 percent died by suicide, compared with 1.4 percent of 72 personality-disordered comparison subjects. Another 14.0 percent of the BPD group died of non-suicide causes. Among those who died by suicide, 87.5 percent had not recovered before death. Prior psychiatric hospitalizations predicted completed suicide (hazard ratio 1.62).

Those two numbers can sit in the same chart. They are not a disagreement you have to pick a winner for. They are different questions: a review ceiling across clinical reports, and a 24-year count in one inpatient-recruited US cohort. If you write “suicide rate 10 percent” with no population, a later reader cannot tell which claim you meant.

Pompili’s 2005 meta-analysis pooled eight follow-up studies (1,179 people with BPD, 94 deaths by suicide, about 8 percent). Completed suicide was more frequent in the earlier phases of follow-up than in later chronic phases. That is a reason to treat those earlier phases as a high-attention window, not a reason to relax because the client has “always been like this.”

Attempt rate versus completed suicide

Keep borderline personality disorder and suicide rates for completed death separate from the attempt count. Attempt histories are the rule in clinical BPD, not the exception. Black, Blum, Pfohl, and Hale (2004) reported that at least three-quarters of patients with BPD attempt suicide and approximately 10 percent eventually die by suicide. They also warned clinicians not to read a pattern of repeated attempts as little desire to die.

Zanarini’s McLean cohort makes the same split visible over time. At the index admission, 79.3 percent of 290 inpatients had a lifetime suicide attempt and 60 percent had multiple attempts; 90 percent had a history of self-mutilation. By years 9 to 10, 12.8 percent reported an attempt in that interval. The course is initially more serious, then more often quieter, and still not zero.

So the note has two jobs. First, do not treat a long attempt history as noise. Second, do not treat today’s denial of plan as a lifetime all-clear because last year’s rate fell. Count the attempts, name the methods, and say what is different this week.

If the clinical question is how you treat life-threatening behavior rather than how you cite a rate, use the DBT techniques for BPD hierarchy before you reach for a skills handout.

Keep risk formulations connected to the session note

Draft clinician-reviewed notes that carry forward risk factors, safety actions, and the next review date.

Start free
  • No credit card
Risk follow-up
Fictional · Next review

Client said

I can call my sister before the urge gets louder.

Draft for your review

Risk formulation: factors, action, and review date ready to check.

Add the next safety step →

What a group rate does not predict

It does not predict this client’s timing. A 24-year cohort rate is silent about Thursday.

It does not predict method, intent, or access to means. Paris notes that attempts in this literature are often overdoses. That is a prompt to ask about medication stores, not a fact about the person in your chair.

It does not cancel acute risk because the client is “chronic.” Black’s review treats prior attempts, comorbid major depression, a substance use disorder, hopelessness, impulsivity, a turbulent early life, and antisocial traits as factors that raise suicidal behavior. Temes adds hospitalization count and unrecovered status. Those are this-person facts. The percentage is not.

It does not replace a screen. When you need the instrument and disposition language, use the suicide risk assessment template. The rate belongs in the rationale. The screen belongs in the findings.

Would you write “10 percent, therefore low today”? Then you have used a base rate as a dismissal. Write the opposite error as well: “10 percent, therefore high forever,” with no session data. Both notes fail the same test. A stranger cannot see why you acted.

What the risk note records

Name four things, in this order: the figure you actually used and its population; this client’s history and current ideation; the factors that raise or lower risk for them; the action that matches the judgment.

The useful sentence is the one that ties the citation to this client: hospitalizations predicted death by suicide in Temes’s cohort, and R.K. has two, so the admission count stays in the rationale. The 5.9 percent figure does not set the level. The session does.

When the next step is a written plan the client leaves with, use the Stanley-Brown safety plan template. When the long view is whether symptoms and function have actually remitted, pair the rate with BPD remission rather than treating diagnosis as a lifetime mortality label.

Keep each field on its own line. Cite borderline personality disorder and suicide rates with their population, then write this client. A rate with no action reads as a statistic you happened to know. A level with no rate can still be defensible. A rate used to skip the screen is not.

Download the target-to-skill selector to match the highest active DBT target to one practical next step before the next session.

Free PDF: DBT BPD Target-to-Skill Selector

A printable hierarchy-first selector for matching life-threatening, therapy-interfering, and quality-of-life targets to one DBT skill family.

  • Hierarchy-stage checkboxes for life-threat, therapy interference, quality of life, and skills
  • Prompting-event and chain-link fields for body cue, thought, urge, action, payoff, and cost
  • Primary skill-family selection with stop-rule and contraindication checks
  • Reviewable practice fields and next-session diary-card review prompts

Free. We'll email the PDF link right away and add you to the therapist toolkit, sent every two weeks. Unsubscribe any time.

References

  • Black, D. W., Blum, N., Pfohl, B., & Hale, N. (2004). Suicidal behavior in borderline personality disorder: Prevalence, risk factors, prediction, and prevention. Journal of Personality Disorders, 18(3), 226-239. PubMed record
  • Paris, J. (2019). Suicidality in borderline personality disorder. Medicina, 55(6), 223. DOI
  • Pompili, M., Girardi, P., Ruberto, A., & Tatarelli, R. (2005). Suicide in borderline personality disorder: A meta-analysis. Nordic Journal of Psychiatry, 59(5), 319-324. DOI
  • Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline FAQs.
  • Temes, C. M., Frankenburg, F. R., Fitzmaurice, G. M., & Zanarini, M. C. (2019). Deaths by suicide and other causes among patients with borderline personality disorder and personality-disordered comparison subjects over 24 years of prospective follow-up. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 80(1), 18m12436. DOI
  • Zanarini, M. C., Frankenburg, F. R., Reich, D. B., Fitzmaurice, G., Weinberg, I., & Gunderson, J. G. (2008). The 10-year course of physically self-destructive acts reported by borderline patients and axis II comparison subjects. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 117(3), 177-184. PMC article

Free PDF: DBT BPD Target-to-Skill Selector

A printable hierarchy-first selector for matching life-threatening, therapy-interfering, and quality-of-life targets to one DBT skill family.

  • Hierarchy-stage checkboxes for life-threat, therapy interference, quality of life, and skills
  • Prompting-event and chain-link fields for body cue, thought, urge, action, payoff, and cost
  • Primary skill-family selection with stop-rule and contraindication checks
  • Reviewable practice fields and next-session diary-card review prompts

Free. We'll email the PDF link right away and add you to the therapist toolkit, sent every two weeks. Unsubscribe any time.

Ready to transform your practice?

Join 10,000+ therapists using Emosapien.