Clinician hands place a blank affidavit into a document sleeve beside a private-contract folder and two-year calendar, linked by a marigold decision fork.
Medicareinsurance billingtherapy practicepractice operations

Medicare Opt-Out List: Therapist Decision Guide

Photo of Andrew Evans
Andrew Evans Clinical Operations Writer 7 min read
Outline

Medicare opt-out list decision table

QuestionIf you stay enrolledIf you opt out
Can you serve Original Medicare clients?Bill covered services when enrollment and claim rules are metUse a compliant private contract for Medicare-covered services, except the urgent or emergency pathway
Who pays for covered therapy?Medicare can pay under the applicable benefit and claim rulesThe client accepts payment responsibility; neither party submits the covered service to Medicare
Can you choose client by client?Enrollment and participation rules applyNo. You cannot opt out for some Medicare clients or services but not others
What documents govern the choice?Enrollment record, payer rules, and claims processSigned affidavit to every relevant Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) plus a private contract with each Medicare client
How long does the choice run?Enrollment remains subject to its own maintenance rulesTwo years, with automatic renewal unless you cancel on time

Free PDF: Insurance Billing Preflight and Denial-Handoff Worksheet

A printable two-page therapy insurance billing worksheet: claim lifecycle map, eligibility and pre-submit checks, denial classification, and weekly AR stand-up.

  • Six-stage claim lifecycle map for therapy practices
  • Eligibility, authorization, intake, and pre-submit checklists
  • Denial ticket with owner, class, due dates, and root-cause fields
  • Fifteen-minute weekly billing stand-up close sheet

Free. We'll email the PDF link right away and add you to the therapist toolkit, sent every two weeks. Unsubscribe any time.

Use this guide to organize the decision with your Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC), billing lead, and counsel or compliance adviser when needed. It does not replace your payer contracts, state-law obligations, or CMS instructions for your circumstances.

Find a provider on the Medicare opt-out list

Use the CMS Provider Opt-Out Affidavits Look-up Tool before you describe a clinician as opted out. Search by NPI when you have it; otherwise search the clinician’s first and last name. The tool’s data comes from PECOS, is updated monthly, and includes data through the last day of the prior month. Record the status information and the date you checked it.

A result in the Medicare opt out list is a status check, not a substitute for your client’s billing facts. Match the NPI, specialty, practice location, and effective dates to the clinician and service at issue. If the result is unclear, ask the MAC that would process the claim rather than treating a name match as a final answer.

Who can opt out

CMS lists clinical psychologists, clinical social workers, marriage and family therapists, and mental health counselors among the providers eligible to opt out. A credential alone does not complete the decision. You still need to confirm your eligibility, enrollment or opt-out status, Medicaid relationships, and the operational ability to use private contracts consistently.

Confirm your license, state authorization, and current MAC instructions before you act. The opt-out rules apply to the individual clinician; a group-practice decision should distinguish each clinician’s status and client arrangements.

Decide whether opt-out fits the practice

Opting out is not a way to make a single service self-pay while keeping the rest of your Medicare work billable. The opt-out affidavit applies to all Medicare-covered items and services the individual clinician furnishes during the opt-out period, subject to the urgent and emergency-care rules. Under 42 CFR Part 405, Subpart D, an opted-out practitioner generally may furnish Medicare-covered items or services to Medicare beneficiaries only through compliant private contracts and may not submit Medicare claims.

Run the decision at the practice level:

  1. Client access: Which current and prospective clients use Original Medicare, and who will need a referral to an enrolled clinician if you opt out?
  2. Service path: Can your intake, scheduling, and billing teams reliably flag Medicare beneficiaries before care is furnished?
  3. Contract path: Can you obtain and retain the required private contract before covered services, rather than using a routine financial-policy signature as a substitute?
  4. Payer relationships: Could opting out affect a Medicare Advantage arrangement or another program that expects Medicare enrollment?
  5. Reversal timing: Can the practice absorb the two-year term and calendar cancellation or the limited first-time termination window?

For a separate claims-workflow view, use insurance billing for therapists. For enrollment readiness, use insurance credentialing for therapists. Your Medicare telehealth eligibility and claim fields belong in the Medicare telehealth mental health guide, not in an opt-out decision.

File the opt-out affidavit with the right MAC

To properly opt out, 42 CFR Part 405, Subpart D requires an affidavit that meets the rule’s specifications to be submitted to each MAC where you would otherwise file claims. Contact each relevant MAC for its current affidavit instructions and required submission process.

The affidavit must be written and signed, identify the practitioner, and include the required acknowledgments about private contracts, Medicare claims, payments, and the scope of the opt-out period. Use the affidavit requirements in 42 CFR Part 405, Subpart D and your MAC’s current instructions. Do not copy a form from another jurisdiction without checking the MAC that has jurisdiction over your claims.

The effective date depends on participation status and filing timing. For a nonparticipating physician or practitioner, the initial period can begin on the date of signature when the affidavit is timely filed after the first private contract. For a participating physician, the rule sets a calendar-quarter pathway with advance filing. Confirm the effective date with your MAC before you promise a client a self-pay arrangement.

Use a private contract with every Medicare client

A private contract is a regulated client agreement, not a general self-pay consent. 42 CFR Part 405, Subpart D requires a written, readable agreement that addresses the client’s payment responsibility, the agreement not to submit a Medicare claim, the lack of Medicare payment for services that otherwise would have been covered, the client’s right to obtain care from clinicians who have not opted out, the two-year term dates, Medigap or supplemental-payment notice, signatures, delivery to the client before services, and retention by the clinician.

The regulation also says you cannot enter a private contract while the beneficiary needs emergency or urgent care. Keep the contract process out of a moment when a client needs immediate care. Use the linked requirements as a checklist, then have your MAC and counsel review your private-contract template before use.

What changes for clients

A client who signs a compliant private contract accepts full responsibility for the clinician’s charge, and Medicare payment is not made for the services that would otherwise be covered. The client remains free to obtain Medicare-covered services from a clinician who has not opted out. State that choice plainly before care begins, and make sure your scheduling team can identify the correct path before the session is furnished.

Medicare Advantage requires a separate verification step. Confirm the client’s plan and current contract requirements before you quote payment responsibility.

Manage the two-year term and exit dates

The opt-out period lasts two years and renews automatically unless you cancel. Under 42 CFR Part 405, Subpart D, cancellation requires written notice to every relevant MAC no later than 30 days before the current term ends. A clinician who is opting out for the first time may terminate early only if the rule’s conditions are met, including notice within 90 days of the initial effective date and required client notices and refunds.

Put the effective date, term end date, 30-day cancellation deadline, and any 90-day first-time review deadline in the same operating calendar your practice uses for enrollment and payer renewals. The Medicare PTAN lookup guide can help keep provider identifiers and contractor questions organized alongside that calendar.

Download the insurance billing preflight worksheet

The insurance billing preflight worksheet gives your practice one place to record payer checks, accountable owners, and source dates before an encounter reaches the claim queue. Use it with the opt-out decision table, then keep the affidavit and private-contract workflow with the staff member who owns Medicare intake. If you need a clinician-reviewed record of the decision and later conversations, use an Emosapien documentation workflow alongside your billing system; it does not replace the MAC, payer portal, or contract review.

Free PDF: Insurance Billing Preflight and Denial-Handoff Worksheet

A printable two-page therapy insurance billing worksheet: claim lifecycle map, eligibility and pre-submit checks, denial classification, and weekly AR stand-up.

  • Six-stage claim lifecycle map for therapy practices
  • Eligibility, authorization, intake, and pre-submit checklists
  • Denial ticket with owner, class, due dates, and root-cause fields
  • Fifteen-minute weekly billing stand-up close sheet

Free. We'll email the PDF link right away and add you to the therapist toolkit, sent every two weeks. Unsubscribe any time.

References

Free PDF: Insurance Billing Preflight and Denial-Handoff Worksheet

A printable two-page therapy insurance billing worksheet: claim lifecycle map, eligibility and pre-submit checks, denial classification, and weekly AR stand-up.

  • Six-stage claim lifecycle map for therapy practices
  • Eligibility, authorization, intake, and pre-submit checklists
  • Denial ticket with owner, class, due dates, and root-cause fields
  • Fifteen-minute weekly billing stand-up close sheet

Free. We'll email the PDF link right away and add you to the therapist toolkit, sent every two weeks. Unsubscribe any time.

Ready to transform your practice?

Join 10,000+ therapists using Emosapien.